89ARIES wrote:The scanner said 20 vacuum, which would be good.
When Butch said that the vacuum was 20 inches at idle and that he thought the engine was still in good shape, I had assumed he used a mechanical vacuum gage connectled to intake manifold and not only looked at idle vacuum but looked carefully at the response to the vacuum gage to various changing conditions to further verify everything in the motor is basically sound. You have continued to say that compression is good. Maybe, a good throrough evaluation of vacuum using a scan instrument can be done, but I suspect checking it with a mechanical gage is better. I think, when you are using a scan instrument, you are relying on a sensor and/or computer within the car to convert the vacuum level to a voltage level. Potential sensor error/conversion errors can occur depending upon how the conversion is being done and the condition/range of the sesnor in your car. It might be fine for measuring a steady state value, but I am not not sure it is best for looking at dynamic changes/responses to view subtle problems. (Maybe I am wrong and professional mechanics don't bother with mechanical vacuum gages anymore.) Sometimes a direct analog instrument readout is better than a sampled or averaged digital readout.
As for the compression being good I don't know why you did not bother to measure the compression when you had the plugs out to check for both level and balance between the cylinders.
However, in general, it sounds like Butch got you car basically running and he seems to feel the engine is basically sound. Can't you just hire Butch or someone else competent that he might recommend (in your local area - there has to be someone competent willing to work on your car) to spend some time running some diagnostic tests (verify spark is ok, - move on the fuel items, like check fuel pump pressure and delivery rate, check throttle position sensor carefully over its full range for dead spots or just change it, test map sensor or just change it, check fuel pressure regulator, check injector, check and/or just replace AIS motor, check pattern of injector spray, maybe clean/rebuilt the TBI etc.). Then, just change whatever is supect. (Most of the potential parts that might be failing are not that expensive. )
Stop worrying about the basic timing setting. Butch just set it. If you have timing problems it is probably becasue your instantanewous timing setting is being set improperly by the computer in response to some sensor prbolem. On the older cars variations in timing over a dynamic range was controlled by a vacuum advance and mechanical advance as part of the distributor. On you car, the dynamic timing curve is controlled by the computer (using a look-up table) and setting timing in response to sensor inputs. I think the timing curves mapped into the computer were less than ideal to start with since the models were rather crude in compariosn to what is done today. Someone with the appropriate scanner/logging device might be able to record what your computer is actually setting the timing dynamically as you are driving the car to see it it looks normal or looks like it is jumping all over the place. (I am not sure if this is an available output from the computer on your car.)